NORTH CAROLINA COURT OF APPEALS No.: COA05-1618
Docket Sheet
As Of: 02/02/2007
Baker v Charlotte Motor Speedway Completed: YES
BRYAN HEATH BAKER, and wife, SUSAN D.
BAKER; TAMMY L. HEPLER, Individually
and as ADMINISTRATRIX of the ESTATE of
JOHN A. HEPLER, III; STEVEN P. VANDERHOOF;
MARGARET F. LINDSAY; and [WALTER
SUDDERTH],
Plaintiffs,
V
CHARLOTTE MOTOR SPEEDWAY, INC.
doing business as LOWE'S MOTOR
SPEEDWAY and TINDALL CORPORATION
formerly, TINDALL CONCRETE PRODUCTS,
INC.,
Defendants.
=======================================================================================
Docketed: 01/17/06 Record: 12/13/05 Acquired: 12/13/05 Bond Coll.: Yes
Docket $: Yes
Pauper: No
Case Type: Civil (Civil_othr) Print Deposit: Yes
State Appeals: No
Mediation: {N - Vetoed by 1 or more firms}
=======================================================================================
| HISTORY |
---------
Venue: Mecklenburg (26) - Heard In: Superior
Case# Location Judge
01CVS10499 Mecklenburg W. Erwin Spainhour
Thomas W. Seay, Jr.
Supreme Court of NC -> To: / / From: / /
=======================================================================================
| TRACKING/ARGUE |
----------------
Next Due: SC RULING Argue(d): 09/13/06 Seq#: 2
Panel Members:
Record on Appeal is: In
First Appellant's Brief is: In
First Appellee's Brief is: In
All Documents Mailed Out: No
=======================================================================================
| DOCUMENTS |
-----------
| | |Date | | Recpt|Cert of |Rec/Brf |Response|Response|Mailed |Ruling
##|Doc| Who|Filed |Fee | # |Service |Due |Due |Recvd |Out |Date
--+---+----+--------+----+-------+--------+--------+--------+--------+--------+--------
==|===|====|========|====|=======|========|========|========|========|========|========
1|Rec|Pl-A|12/13/05| 10|60603 |12/12/05| / / |********|********|01/26/06|********
==|===|====|========|====|=======|========|========|========|========|========|========
2|Rec|Pl-A|12/13/05| 0| |12/12/05| / / |********|********| / / |********
==|===|====|========|====|=======|========|========|========|========|========|========
3|Rec|Pl-A|12/13/05| 0| |12/12/05| / / |********|********| / / |********
==|===|====|========|====|=======|========|========|========|========|========|========
4|Rec|Pl-A|12/13/05| 0| |12/12/05| / / |********|********| / / |********
==|===|====|========|====|=======|========|========|========|========|========|========
5|Rec|Pl-A|12/13/05| 0| |12/13/05| / / |********|********| / / |********
6|Mot|Pl-A|02/21/06| 0| |02/17/06|03/29/06| / / | / / |********|02/21/06
7|Mot|De-C|02/22/06| 0| |02/21/06| / / |03/07/06|03/06/06|********|09/21/06
8|Mot|De-B|03/03/06| 0| |02/28/06| / / |03/14/06|03/13/06|********|09/21/06
9|Mot|Pl-A|03/22/06| 0| |03/21/06|04/28/06| / / | / / |********|03/24/06
10|Apt|Pl-A|04/28/06| 0| | / / | / / | / / | / / |05/02/06|********
11|Inf|Pl-A|05/01/06|****|*******|04/28/06|********|********|********| / / | / /
12|Ape|De-C|05/26/06| 0| | / / | / / | / / | / / |05/31/06|********
13|Ape|De-B|05/30/06| 0| | / / | / / | / / | / / |06/01/06|********
=======================================================================================
1 - Record IN Filed: 12/13/2005 @ 9:03
Filed by [A] Blount - THE BLOUNT LAW FIRM for Plaintiff-Appellant Walter
Sudderth -
=======================================================================================
2 - Record IN Filed: 12/13/2005 @ 9:03
Filed by [A] Blount - THE BLOUNT LAW FIRM for Plaintiff-Appellant Walter
Sudderth -
=======================================================================================
3 - Record IN Filed: 12/13/2005 @ 9:03
Filed by [A] Blount - THE BLOUNT LAW FIRM for Plaintiff-Appellant Walter
Sudderth -
=======================================================================================
4 - Record IN Filed: 12/13/2005 @ 9:03
Filed by [A] Blount - THE BLOUNT LAW FIRM for Plaintiff-Appellant Walter
Sudderth -
=======================================================================================
5 - Record IN Filed: 12/13/2005 @ 9:03
Filed by [A] Blount - THE BLOUNT LAW FIRM for Plaintiff-Appellant Walter
Sudderth -
=======================================================================================
6 - Motion For Extension Of Time Within Which To File Appellant's Brief Filed: 02/21/2006
Filed by [A] Blount - THE BLOUNT LAW FIRM for Plaintiff-Appellant Walter
Sudderth - allowed in part. Plaintiff-appellant's brief shall be filed on
or before 29 March 2006
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
7 - Motion Defendant-Appellee Tindall Corporation's Motion To Dismiss Appeal Filed: 02/22/2006
Filed by [C] Williams - BROOKS PIERCE MCLENDON for Defendant-Appellee
Tindall Corporation - denied
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
8 - Motion Defendant-Appellee Charlotte Motor Speedway, Inc.'s Motion To Dismiss Appeal Filed: 03/03/2006
Filed by [B] Allen - PARKER POE ADAMS & BERNSTEIN for Defendant-Appellee
Charlotte Motor Speedway - denied
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
9 - Motion For Extension Of Time Within Which To File Appellant's Brief Filed: 03/22/2006
Filed by [A] Blount - THE BLOUNT LAW FIRM for Plaintiff-Appellant Walter
Sudderth - allowed. Plaintiff-appellant's brief shall be filed on or before
28 April 2006
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
10 - Apt Brief IN Filed: 04/28/2006 @ 12:36
Filed by [A] Blount - THE BLOUNT LAW FIRM for Plaintiff-Appellant Walter
Sudderth - [ELECTRONICALLY FILED]
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
11 - Information Sheet INFORM SHT Filed: 05/01/2006 @ 8:43
Filed by [A] Blount - THE BLOUNT LAW FIRM for Plaintiff-Appellant Walter
Sudderth -
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
12 - Apee Brief IN Filed: 05/26/2006 @ 09:56
Filed by [C] Williams - BROOKS PIERCE MCLENDON for Defendant-Appellee
Tindall Corporation - [ELECTRONICALLY FILED]
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
13 - Apee Brief IN Filed: 05/30/2006 @ 15:47
Filed by [B] Allen - PARKER POE ADAMS & BERNSTEIN for Defendant-Appellee
Charlotte Motor Speedway - [ELECTRONICALLY FILED]
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
=======================================================================================
| RECEIPTS |
----------
Date Total Deposit Bal
Charged Billed Amount Paid Receipt# Pages
01/17/06 250.00 0.00 01/17/06 60603 0
For: Bond [To Be Paid By: Atty]
Filed By: Marvin K. Blount of THE BLOUNT LAW FIRM for Plaintiff-Appellant Walter Sudderth
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
01/17/06 10.00 0.00 01/17/06 60603 0
For: Docket Fee [To Be Paid By: Atty]
Filed By: Marvin K. Blount of THE BLOUNT LAW FIRM for Plaintiff-Appellant Walter Sudderth
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
01/26/06 7.00 1694.00 02/13/06 60856 972
For: Printing: Record. Filed 12/13/2005 (972 pages) [To Be Paid By: Atty]
Filed By: Marvin K. Blount of THE BLOUNT LAW FIRM for Plaintiff-Appellant Walter Sudderth
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
05/02/06 3.50 66.50 05/05/06 61815 40
For: Printing: Appellant Brief. - {in} - Filed 04/28/2006 (40 pages) [To Be Paid By: Atty]
Filed By: Marvin K. Blount of THE BLOUNT LAW FIRM for Plaintiff-Appellant Walter Sudderth
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
05/31/06 64.75 0.00 06/16/06 62270 37
For: Printing: Appellee Brief. - {in} - Filed 05/26/2006 (37 pages) [To Be Paid By: Atty]
Filed By: James T. Williams of BROOKS PIERCE MCLENDON for Defendant-Appellee Tindall Corporation
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
06/01/06 59.50 0.00 06/07/06 62172 34
For: Printing: Appellee Brief. - {in} - Filed 05/30/2006 (34 pages) [To Be Paid By: Atty]
Filed By: David N. Allen of PARKER POE ADAMS & BERNSTEIN for Defendant-Appellee Charlotte Motor Speedway
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
11/27/06 -59.50 0.00 11/27/06 0 0
For: Disburse [To Be Paid By: Atty]
Filed By: David N. Allen of PARKER POE ADAMS & BERNSTEIN for Defendant-Appellee Charlotte Motor Speedway
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
11/27/06 -64.75 0.00 11/27/06 0 0
For: Disburse [To Be Paid By: Atty]
Filed By: James T. Williams of BROOKS PIERCE MCLENDON for Defendant-Appellee Tindall Corporation
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
11/27/06 -116.75 0.00 11/27/06 0 0
For: Disburse [To Be Paid By: Atty]
Filed By: Marvin K. Blount of THE BLOUNT LAW FIRM for Plaintiff-Appellant Walter Sudderth
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
=======================================================================================
| OPINION |
---------
Opinion Date: 11/21/06 Cert. Date: 12/11/06
Author: Elmore, J.
Decision: Affirmed
Opinion Notes: Steelman(c)
Op_Pages: 14 Opinion_$: 2.80 Cite:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Judgment...
Result: No Error Found
Amount: 133.25
Payer: Plaintiffs
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Certificate of Satisfaction Issued: 01/11/2007
To: Honorable Martha H. Curran, Clerk Mecklenburg County Superior Court
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
=======================================================================================
| TO/FROM SCONC |
---------------
1 - COA Received Request: 01/03/07 SCONC#: 642P06 Cert Fee: $0.00
Sent to SCONC: / / Lower Ct. Ltr Sent: / /
Cert Orig. Folder: No Cert Record = 0 Volumes Transcript = 0 Volumes
Exhibits: {Not Sent to SC}
----------------------------------------------
Apnt Apee Other Other Date Date
Rec Brf Brf Brf Brf Adndm Sent Ret
0 0 0 0 0 0 / / / /
----------------------------------------------
Appeal Type: PDR filed by Blount of THE BLOUNT LAW FIRM for Plaintiff-Appellant Walter Sudderth -
PDR RULING: / / -
=======================================================================================
| EXHIBITS |
----------
Exhibit/Transcript for this case:
Received on/from:
Exhibit/Transcript Information
* Supplement to Record on Appeal Filed Pursuant to Rule 11(c);
pages 1-842
* Transcript of the Hearing; pages 1-6
* Transcript of the Hearing; pages 1-35
* Transcript of the Hearing; pages 1-188
=======================================================================================
| NATURE |
----------
AIS= 0 of 1 Received
=======================================================================================
| PARTIES |
---------
Baker, Bryan Heath (Plaintiff) (Appellee)
Baker, Susan D. (Plaintiff) (Appellee)
Charlotte Motor Speedway, Inc (Defendant) (Appellee)
Hepler, Curtis D. (Plaintiff) (Appellee)
Hepler, John A. (III) (Plaintiff) (Appellee)
Hepler, Patricia B. (Plaintiff) (Appellee)
Hepler, Tammy L. (Plaintiff) (Appellee)
Lindsey, Margaret F. (Plaintiff) (Appellee)
Lowe's Motor Speedway (Defendant) (Appellee)
Sudderth, Walter (Plaintiff) (Appellant)
Tindall Concrete Products, In (Defendant) (Appellee)
Tindall Corporation (Defendant) (Appellee)
Vanderhoof, Steven P. (Plaintiff) (Appellee)
Williams, Craig A. (Plaintiff) (Appellee)
Williams, Crystal L. (Plaintiff) (Appellee)
=======================================================================================
| ATTORNEYS |
-----------
[Attorney for Plaintiff-Appellant Walter Sudderth]
Appellate Information Statement Received
Mr. Marvin K. Blount [PRIMARY ATTY]
Attorney at Law [A]
Mr. Darren Dawson
Mr. Harry H. Albritton, Jr.
Ms. Rebecca C. Blount
THE BLOUNT LAW FIRM
Post Office Drawer 58
Greenville, NC 27835-0058
252-752-6000
Mediation - Form returned: 02/06/06 Answer: Yes- (COA)
--------------------------------------------------------
[Attorney for Defendant-Appellee Charlotte Motor Speedway]
Mr. David N. Allen [PRIMARY ATTY]
Attorney at Law [B]
Ms. Lori R. Keeton
Mr. Jason R. Benton
PARKER POE ADAMS & BERNSTEIN
Three Wachovia Center
Suite 3000
Charlotte, NC 28202
704-372-9000
Mediation - Form returned: 02/08/06 Answer: No - (N/A)
--------------------------------------------------------
[Attorney for Defendant-Appellee Tindall Corporation]
Mr. James T. Williams [PRIMARY ATTY]
Attorney at Law [C]
Mr. Reid L. Phillips
Mr. Robert J. King
Ms. Teresa DeLoatch Bryant
BROOKS PIERCE MCLENDON
HUMPHREY & LEONARD, LLP
Post Office Box 26000
Greensboro, NC 27420-6000
Mediation - Form returned: 02/06/06 Answer: No - (N/A)
--------------------------------------------------------