STATE OF NORTH CAROLINA
v. Forsyth County
Nos. 02 CRS 63586,
ANTONIO GARCIA DUARTE 03 CRS 6165
Attorney General Roy Cooper, by Assistant Attorney General Amy
C. Kunstling, for the State.
Nancy R. Gaines for defendant-appellant.
LEVINSON, Judge.
On 24 March 2003, the Forsyth County grand jury indicted
Antonio Garcia Durante (defendant) on charges of conspiracy to
traffic in cocaine by both transportation and possession and of
trafficking in cocaine by both transportation and possession. At
a hearing on 26 April 2004, the trial court allowed the State's
motion to join a co-defendant and all offenses for trial. As the
trial court began hearing evidence regarding a motion to suppress
which had been filed by the co-defendant, counsel for defendant
stated defendant was adopting the motion at that time. At the
conclusion of the hearing and after hearing argument from counsel,
the trial court took the matter under advisement.
On 24 June 2004, defendant pled guilty to lesser-includedoffenses of the four counts in the indictments pursuant to a plea
arrangement. He also pled guilty to a charge of possession with
intent to sell and deliver cocaine. According to the transcript of
plea, defendant reserved his right to appeal the denial of a motion
to suppress. The trial court consolidated the offenses into two
judgments and imposed consecutive sentences with a combined term of
105 to 126 months imprisonment. From the trial court's judgments,
defendant appealed.
Defendant contends the trial court erred by denying his motion
to suppress. He argues the trial court failed to conduct a
balancing test under N.C.R. Evid. 403 of the relative probative and
prejudicial impact of the evidence found in a co-defendant's
vehicle. The record on appeal does not support defendant's
argument.
This Court is bound by the record before it, and in the
absence of anything in the record to indicate otherwise, must
assume that the trial judge ruled properly on matters before him,
correctly applying the applicable law. State v. Williams, 304
N.C. 394, 415, 284 S.E.2d 437, 451 (1981). As the appellant,
defendant had the duty and responsibility of seeing that the record
before this Court was complete. State v. Alston, 307 N.C. 321,
341, 298 S.E.2d 631, 644 (1983). The 26 April 2004 transcript
contains a statement by defendant's counsel that he was adopting
the co-defendant's motion to suppress. In the statement of the
case contained in his brief, defendant described it as a motion to
suppress evidence obtained through an illegal search and seizurewhich the trial court denied in open court on 9 June 2004. Briefs,
however, are not a part of the record on appeal. See N.C.R. App.
P. 9(a); see also Ronald G. Hinson Electric, Inc. v. Union County
Bd. of Educ., 125 N.C. App. 373, 375, 481 S.E.2d 326, 328 (1997).
Aside from defendant's statement in open court that he was
adopting his co-defendant's motion to suppress and the reservation
of his right of appeal the denial of his motion to suppress found
in his transcript of plea, the record before this court contains
nothing about a motion to suppress by defendant. While the record
does contain a motion in limine by defendant, its purpose was to
have the trial court prohibit any mention during trial of the
State's confidential informant and his activities rather than to
suppress evidence found in the co-defendant's vehicle.
Nowhere in the record does there appear an order by the trial
court denying a motion to suppress by defendant. Nor is there any
record before this Court of the proceedings on 9 June 2004 in which
the trial court allegedly made its findings of fact and denied the
co-defendant's motion to suppress. This Court cannot review the
action of a trial court when that action does not appear of record.
See N.C.R. App. P. 9(a)(3)(g) (specifying that the record on appeal
in criminal cases shall contain copies of the judgment, order, or
other determination from which appeal is taken). Accordingly,
this appeal is dismissed.
Dismissed.
Judges TYSON and BRYANT concur.
Report per Rule 30(e).
*** Converted from WordPerfect ***