SUPREME COURT OF NORTH CAROLINA Docket#: 681PA01
Full Docket Sheet
Last Updated: 10/20/2003
In the Matter of Greens of Pine Glen Completed: Yes
IN THE MATTER OF APPEAL OF:
THE GREENS OF PINE GLEN LTD.
PARTNERSHIP FROM THE DECISION
OF THE DURHAM COUNTY BOARD OF
EQUALIZATION AND REVIEW
REGARDING THE VALUATION OF
CERTAIN REAL PROPERTY FOR TAX
YEAR 1997
=============================================================================
Docketed: 12/20/2001 Acquired: 12/20/2001 Bond Coll.: No
Appeal Type: PDR/NA - Notice of Appeal & Petition for Discretionary Review
Has Been Allowed on 03/06/2002
Case Type: Civil (Civil_othr) Capital: No Pauper: No
Rule 16b: No
==================================HISTORY====================================
Venue: Property Tax Commission (10)
Previous: NC Court of Appeals
Case# Location Judge
97PTC427 Wake Property Tax Commission
COA00-1218 NC Court of Appeals Property Tax Commission
=================================TRACKING====================================
Next Due: DONE Due on: / / Argue(d): 09/09/2002 Seq#: 5
Record on Appeal is: Not In
First Appellant's Brief is: In
First Appellee's Brief is: In
=============================DOCUMENTS FILED=================================
Type Date Who Brief/Rec Response Mailed Ruling
Filed Filed Due/In Due/In Out Date
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Notice/App 12/20/01 [A] / / / / / / 03/06/02
NA-CQ - Dismissed
Filed By: [Curtis Massey] of County of Durham for Appellant Durham
County
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Petition 12/20/01 [A] / / 01/02/02 01/08/02 03/06/02
PDR - Allowed
Filed By: [Curtis Massey] of County of Durham for Appellant Durham
County
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Motion 01/02/02 [B] / / / / ******** 03/06/02
to Dismiss Appeal --> Allowed
Filed By: [Charles C. Meeker] of Parker, Poe, Adams for Appellee Greens
of Pine Glen, Ltd.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Petition 01/02/02 [B] / / / / / / 03/06/02
PDR-C - Denied
Filed By: [Charles C. Meeker] of Parker, Poe, Adams for Appellee Greens
of Pine Glen, Ltd.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Motion 01/30/02 [C] / / / / ******** 03/06/02
for Leave to File Amicus Curiae Brief in Support of
Appellee Durham County --> Allowed
Filed By: [James B. Blackburn for Amicus N.C. Assoc. of County Comm.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Other Brief 01/30/02 [C] / / ******** 03/12/02 ********
AMICUS -
Filed By: [James B. Blackburn for Amicus N.C. Assoc. of County Comm.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Apt Brief 04/05/02 [A] / / ******** 04/09/02 ********
Filed By: [Curtis Massey] of County of Durham for Appellant Durham
County
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Apee Brief 05/06/02 [B] / / ******** 05/08/02 ********
Filed By: [Charles C. Meeker] of Parker, Poe, Adams for Appellee Greens
of Pine Glen, Ltd.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Motion 05/06/02 [D] / / / / ******** 05/07/02
for Leave to file Amicus Curiae Brief --> Allowed
Filed By: [Susan Ellinger] of Moore & Van Allen, PLLC for Amicus Low
Income Housing Coalition
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Other Brief 05/08/02 [D] / / ******** 05/14/02 ********
AMICUS -
Filed By: [Susan Ellinger] of Moore & Van Allen, PLLC for Amicus Low
Income Housing Coalition
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Motion 05/10/02 [A] 05/22/02 / / ******** 05/14/02
For Extension of Time to File Reply Brief --> Allowed
Filed By: [Curtis Massey] of County of Durham for Appellant Durham
County
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Other Brief 05/23/02 [A] / / ******** 05/27/02 ********
APNT-REPLY -
Filed By: [Curtis Massey] of County of Durham for Appellant Durham
County
==================================OPINION====================================
Opinion Date: 02/28/2003 Cert. Date: 03/20/2003
Author: Edmunds, J.
Decision: Reversed and Remanded
Opinion Notes: Justice Brady did not participate in the consideration or
decision of this case.
Op_Pages: 16 Opinion_$: 3.20
Cite: 356 NC 642
Petition Cite(s): 355 N.C. 286
==================================PARTIES====================================
Durham County (Other Role) (Appellant)
Greens of Pine Glen Ltd. (Other Role) (Appellee)
=================================RECEIPTS====================================
Charged Amount Paid Receipt# Pages
12/20/2001 20.00 01/07/2002 3829 0
For: Docket Fee
Filed By: [Curtis Massey] of County of Durham for Appellant Durham
County
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
01/08/2002 89.25 01/24/2002 3883 51
For: Printing: Petition. - PDR - Filed 12/20/2001
Filed By: [Curtis Massey] of County of Durham for Appellant Durham
County
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
03/12/2002 75.25 07/01/2002 4261 43
For: Printing: AMICUS Brief. Filed 01/30/2002
Filed By: [James B. Blackburn for Amicus N.C. Assoc. of County Comm.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
04/09/2002 115.50 05/13/2002 4140 66
For: Printing: Appellant Brief. Filed 04/05/2002
Filed By: [Curtis Massey] of County of Durham for Appellant Durham
County
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
05/08/2002 73.50 05/13/2002 4150 42
For: Printing: Appellee Brief. Filed 05/06/2002
Filed By: [Charles C. Meeker] of Parker, Poe, Adams for Appellee Greens
of Pine Glen, Ltd.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
05/14/2002 47.25 06/03/2002 4191 27
For: Printing: AMICUS Brief. Filed 05/08/2002
Filed By: [Susan Ellinger] of Moore & Van Allen, PLLC for Amicus Low
Income Housing Coalition
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
05/27/2002 113.75 06/18/2002 4239 65
For: Printing: APNT-REPLY Brief. Filed 05/23/2002
Filed By: [Curtis Massey] of County of Durham for Appellant Durham
County
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
03/20/2003 347.50 04/08/2003 4927 0
For: Judgment
Filed By: [Charles C. Meeker] of Parker, Poe, Adams for Appellee Greens
of Pine Glen, Ltd.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
04/10/2003 -338.50 04/10/2003 3210 0
For: Check
Filed By: [Curtis Massey] of County of Durham for Appellant Durham
County
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
=================================ATTORNEYS===================================
[Attorney for Appellant Durham County]
Mr. [Curtis Massey] [PRIMARY ATTY]
Attorney at Law [A]
County of Durham
Office of the County Attorney
P. 0. Box 3508
Durham, NC 27702
919-560-0715
---------------------------------------------------
[Attorney for Appellee Greens of Pine Glen, Ltd.]
Mr. [Charles C. Meeker] [PRIMARY ATTY]
Attorney at Law [B]
Mr. Jason J. Kaus, Attorney at Law, [Mr. William H. McCullough], Attorney at Law
Parker, Poe, Adams
& Bernstein, L.L.P.
P. 0. Box 389
Raleigh, NC 27602-0389
828-0564
---------------------------------------------------
[Attorney for Amicus N.C. Assoc. of County Comm.]
Mr. [James B. Blackburn, III] [PRIMARY ATTY]
General Counsel [C]
P.O. Box 1488
Raleigh, NC 27602
715-2893
---------------------------------------------------
[Attorney for Amicus Low Income Housing Coalition]
Ms. [Susan Ellinger] [PRIMARY ATTY]
Attorney at Law [D]
[Mr. Charles H. Mercer, Jr., Attorney at Law, for Low Income Housing Coalition]
[Mr. Marc C. Tucker, Attorney at Law, for Low Income Housing Coalition]
Moore & Van Allen, PLLC
P. O. Box 26507
Raleigh, NC 27611-6507
919-821-6200
---------------------------------------------------