Supreme Court of North Carolina - Petitions

SUPREME COURT OF NORTH CAROLINA

PETITIONS

Decided by the Court in Conference: 15 June 2000
{Posted on the Internet Web Site: 16 June 2000 at 1:30 p.m.}

COMMON ABBREVIATIONS

Abbreviation Full Term

PWC Petition for Writ of Certiorari

MAR Motion for Appropriate Relief

COA North Carolina Court of Appeals

MTS Motion for Temporary Stay

Def Defendant

NOA Notice of Appeal

Plt Plaintiff

PDR Petition for Discretionary Review

Cert Certiorari

AG Attorney General

11P99 - 2* Performance Friction v. Jens Lamba 1. Plts' Motion for Temp. Stay
2. Plts' Pet. for Writ of Supersedeas 1. Denied
2. Denied

19P00 State v. Nicholas Corral Def's PDR Denied

55P99 - 2 Lassie Sharpe v. David Worland, et. al. Plts' PDR Denied

56PA00* James H. Pou Bailey v. State Plts' Motion to Dismiss Appeal for Lack of Subject Matter Jurisdiction Denied

76P00 Wilbert Neal v. NC St. Bar, Douglas Brocker & James Dorsett Plt's Pro Se Pet. for Writ of Mandamus Denied

83P00 Jewel Williams v. Family Dollar Stores Plt's PDR Denied

86P00 Piedmont Triad Regional Water Authority v. Sumner Hills Inc. & Denmark Golf Services 1. Def's PDR
2. Plt's Conditional PDR 1. Allowed
2. Allowed

90P00 State v. Clifton Ferrell 1. Def's Pro Se PDR
2. Def's Pro Se NOA
3. AG's Motion to Dismiss Appeal 1. - - -
2. Denied
3. Allowed

93P00 State v. Conrad Volcy Def's Pro Se PWC Denied

93A93 - 2 State v. Jaime Duarte Sierra Def's Pro Se PWC Denied

100P94 - 2 State v. Bernard Lee Penn 1. Def's Pro Se PWC
2. Def's Pro Se Motion to Proceed in Forma Pauperis 1. Denied
2. Allowed

107P00 Carroll Stephenson, Jr. v. Town of Garner, Ronnie Williams, Jackie Johns, Sr. & John Adams Plt's PDR Denied

110P00 State v. Donia Rice 1. Def's NOA
2. Def's PDR
3. AG's Motion to Dismiss 1. - - -
2. Denied
3. Allowed

123P00 State v. Frankie Lee Calhoun Def's Pro Se PWC Denied

127P00 Donald Carrington v. Mary Sue Brown, in her official capacity as Chairman of ESC of NC Plt's PDR
Denied
05/15/00

Martin, J. Recused

128P00 State v. Larry Johnson Def's PDR Denied

129P00 State v. Aaron Ingram Def's PDR Denied

130P00 Bovis Construction Corp. v. Western Massachusetts Life Care Corp. Plt's PDR Denied

132P00 Michael Anderson v. State, County of Scotland, Solicitor's Office Plt's Pro Se Pet. for Writ of Mandamus
Denied
05/04/00

158P00 Willie Harris, employee v. Town of Atlantic Beach, Employer 1. Plt's PDR
2. Plt's PWC to review Order of NC Industrial Comm. 1. Denied
2. Denied

159P00 State v. Kenneth Wiggins 1. Def's NOA
2. Def's PDR
3. AG's Motion to Dismiss Appeal 1. - - -
2. Denied
3. Allowed

159A93 - 4 State v. Ernest Basden Def's PWC Denied

160P00 John Parnell, Jr., v. Hartsell, Hartsell & White Plt's PDR
Denied
05/15/00

161P00 Barbara Shaut v. Amy Cannon Plt's PDR
Denied
05/15/00

162P00 Glenda Walker v. Wayne Coble, Richard Frye, Fidelity and Deposit Co. of Maryland and Aetna Insurance Co. Plt's PDR Denied

163P00 Broadus Crabtree v. City of Durham, Michael Ellis & Nationwide Ins. Co. Def's (City of Durham) PDR Denied

165P00 Fred Shannonhouse, Employee v. Weyerhaeuser Co., Employer Def's PDR Denied

168P00 State v. Reginald Aaron Holmes Def's Pro Se Motion for Appropriate Relief
Denied

172P00 Popkin Brothers Enterprises, Inc. v. Bd. of Adjustment of Jacksonville & City of Jacksonville Plaintiff's PDR Denied

173P00 Terry Clark v. Host Marriott Corp. Plt's PDR Denied

174P00 Willie B. Tart v. James Martin & Peggy Martin Defs' PDR Allowed

175P00 State v. Steven Clarence Leazer 1. AG's Motion for Temp. Stay

2. AG's Pet. for Writ of Supersedeas
3. AG's PDR
4. Def's Motion to Dissolve Stay
1. Allowed
04/24/00
2. Allowed
3. Allowed
4. Denied

176P00 State v. Thomas Joseph Edvin Def's Pro Se PWC Denied

177P00 State v. Bobby Junior Locklear Def's Pro Se PWC Denied

178P00 State v. Reginald Sherwood Grady 1. Def's Pro Se NOA
2. Def's Pro Se PWC
3. AG's Motion to Dismiss Appeal 1. - - -
2. Denied
3. Allowed

180P00 State v. Wonald Westmoreland Def's Pro Se PWC Denied

184P00 State v. Carl Jeffreys Def's PDR Denied

187P00 State v. Penny Elizabeth Jarrett Def's PDR Denied

188P00 Tony Dale Howell v. John Wilson & NC Farm Bureau Mutual Ins. Co. Plt's PDR Denied

189P00 State v. Stephen Clay Jones, Sr. 1. Def's NOA
2. Def's PDR
3. AG's Motion to Dismiss Appeal 1. - - -
2. Denied
3. Allowed
Justice Wainwright Recused

191P00 State v. James D. Rich 1. Def's Pro Se PWC
2. Def's Pro Se Motion to Proceed In Forma Pauperis 1. Denied
2. Allowed

194P00 State v. Pearly Junior Rhodie Def's Pro Se PWC Denied

198P00 State v. Raymond Shelton 1. Def's Pro Se PWC
2. Def's Pro Se Petition to Amend PWC 1. Denied
2. Allowed

199P00 State v. Melvin Ollison, Jr. Def's PDR Denied

200P00 Ricky Jay Murakami v. Wilmington Star News, Inc. Plt's PDR Denied

202P00 State v. George Lesane 1. Def's NOA
2. Def's PDR
3. AG's Motion to Dismiss Appeal 1. - - -
2. Denied
3. Allowed

203P00 Ted F. Cash v. State Farm Mutual Auto Ins. Co. Plt's PDR Allowed

204P00 State v. George Lewis Cates 1. Def's NOA
2. Def's PDR
3. State's Motion to Dismiss 1. - - -
2. Denied
3. Allowed

208P00 James Whitaker v. Peggy Akers Def's PDR Denied

209P00 State v. Arcadia Logan Jenkins 1. Def's NOA
2. Def's PDR
3. AG's Motion to Dismiss Appeal 1. - - -
2. Denied
3. Allowed

226P00 State v. Freddie Pickett & Derrick Foreman 1. AG's Motion for Temp. Stay
2. AG's Pet. for Writ of Supersedeas
3. AG's PDR
4. Def Foreman's Conditional PDR as to additional issues 1. Denied
2. Denied
3. Denied
4. Denied

267PA99 Alex H. Thompson & wife, Sheila Thompson v. Michael S. Waters, d/b/a/ Waterhouse Realty & Construction & Lee County Def's (Lee County) Petition for Rehearing Denied

312A99 Sharon Lovelace, et. al. v. City of Shelby Def's Pet. for Rehearing Denied

323A92 - 4 State v. Charles Alonzo Tunstall Def's Pro Se PWC Denied

359P99 - 2 State v. Brian Ellis Def's Pro Se PWC Denied

379A95 - 2 State v. Jeffrey Karl Meyer Def's Motion to Amend the Record on Appeal Item 1.Allowed
Item 2. Denied

385P99 William Ruff et.al. v. Parex, Inc., Sto Corp., W.R. Bonsal Co., Continental Stucco Products, Senergy, & Thomas Waterproof Coatings, Dryvit Systems, US Gypsum & Shields Industries 1. Defs' (Parex, Sto Corp., Continental Stucco Products & Dryvit Systems) Pet. for Writ of Supersedeas
2. Defs' (Parex, Sto Corp., Continental Stucco Products & Dryvit) PWC
3. Def's (US Gypsum) PWC

4. Def's (US Gypsum ) Pet. for Writ of Supersedeas

5. Def's (W.R. Bonsal's) Pet. for Writ of Supersedeas

6. Def's (W.R. Bonsal's) PWC
1. Dismissed as Moot
05/23/00
2. Dismissed as Moot
05/23/00
3. Dismissed as Moot
05/23/00
4. Dismissed as Moot
05/23/00
5. Dismissed as Moot
05/23/00
6. Dismissed as Moot
05/23/00

435PA99 Tammie Dobson v. Holly Harris & J.C. Penney Co. Def's Motion to Strike
Allowed

447P99 - 2 State v. Herbert Chavis Def's Pro Se Motion for Withdrawal of Attorney Allowed

480A99 State v. Donald Scanlon 1. Def's Motion for Appropriate Relief

2. Def's Motion for Add't. Time for Oral Argument
1. Allowed
See Special Order
2. Denied
05/15/00

484A95 - 2 State v. John McNeil Def's PWC Denied

490A93 - 3 State v. Raymond Rowsey 1. Def's PWC to Review Order of Sup. Ct.
2. Def's Pet. for Writ of Supersedeas 1. Denied

2. Denied

515P99 - 2* Haywood Cannon v Gladys Wiggins Cannon, deceased, Norman Wiggins, Administrator Plt's Pro Se Pet. for Writ of Habeas Corpus Denied
05/17/00

Justices Wainwright & Martin Recused

547A88 - 3 State of NC v. Kenneth Lee Boyd Def's PWC Denied

567A99 State of NC v. Timothy Earl Blackwell Def's Pro Se Motion to Set Bail Dismissed

579PA99 State v. Lamont Claxton Underwood Def's Counsel's Motion to Withdraw Allowed
05/11/00

581P99* Vonda C. Trexler v David Pollock Def's (Hugh Chatham Memorial Hospital) Motion to Strike Plaintiff's Pet. & Response to Plt's Pet. for Certiorari Dismissed as Moot
05/08/00

582PA99 John Frost & Carolyn Frost v. Mazda Motor of America & Primus Automotive Financial Services 1. Plts' Motion to Dismiss Appeal
2. Plts' Motion to Withdraw Motion to Dismiss Appeal 1. - - -
2. Allowed

590A99 - 2 State v. David Hunter Def's PWC Denied

Abbreviation	Full Term
PWC	Petition for Writ of Certiorari
MAR	Motion for Appropriate Relief
COA	North Carolina Court of Appeals
MTS	Motion for Temporary Stay
Def	Defendant
NOA	Notice of Appeal
Plt	Plaintiff
PDR	Petition for Discretionary Review
Cert	Certiorari
AG	Attorney General

11P99 - 2*	Performance Friction v. Jens Lamba	1. Plts' Motion for Temp. Stay 2. Plts' Pet. for Writ of Supersedeas	1. Denied 2. Denied
19P00	State v. Nicholas Corral	Def's PDR	Denied
55P99 - 2	Lassie Sharpe v. David Worland, et. al.	Plts' PDR	Denied
56PA00*	James H. Pou Bailey v. State	Plts' Motion to Dismiss Appeal for Lack of Subject Matter Jurisdiction	Denied
76P00	Wilbert Neal v. NC St. Bar, Douglas Brocker & James Dorsett	Plt's Pro Se Pet. for Writ of Mandamus	Denied
83P00	Jewel Williams v. Family Dollar Stores	Plt's PDR	Denied
86P00	Piedmont Triad Regional Water Authority v. Sumner Hills Inc. & Denmark Golf Services	1. Def's PDR 2. Plt's Conditional PDR	1. Allowed 2. Allowed
90P00	State v. Clifton Ferrell	1. Def's Pro Se PDR 2. Def's Pro Se NOA 3. AG's Motion to Dismiss Appeal	1. - - - 2. Denied 3. Allowed
93P00	State v. Conrad Volcy	Def's Pro Se PWC	Denied
93A93 - 2	State v. Jaime Duarte Sierra	Def's Pro Se PWC	Denied
100P94 - 2	State v. Bernard Lee Penn	1. Def's Pro Se PWC 2. Def's Pro Se Motion to Proceed in Forma Pauperis	1. Denied 2. Allowed
107P00	Carroll Stephenson, Jr. v. Town of Garner, Ronnie Williams, Jackie Johns, Sr. & John Adams	Plt's PDR	Denied
110P00	State v. Donia Rice	1. Def's NOA 2. Def's PDR 3. AG's Motion to Dismiss	1. - - - 2. Denied 3. Allowed
123P00	State v. Frankie Lee Calhoun	Def's Pro Se PWC	Denied
127P00	Donald Carrington v. Mary Sue Brown, in her official capacity as Chairman of ESC of NC	Plt's PDR	Denied 05/15/00 Martin, J. Recused
128P00	State v. Larry Johnson	Def's PDR	Denied
129P00	State v. Aaron Ingram	Def's PDR	Denied
130P00	Bovis Construction Corp. v. Western Massachusetts Life Care Corp.	Plt's PDR	Denied
132P00	Michael Anderson v. State, County of Scotland, Solicitor's Office	Plt's Pro Se Pet. for Writ of Mandamus	Denied 05/04/00
158P00	Willie Harris, employee v. Town of Atlantic Beach, Employer	1. Plt's PDR 2. Plt's PWC to review Order of NC Industrial Comm.	1. Denied 2. Denied
159P00	State v. Kenneth Wiggins	1. Def's NOA 2. Def's PDR 3. AG's Motion to Dismiss Appeal	1. - - - 2. Denied 3. Allowed
159A93 - 4	State v. Ernest Basden	Def's PWC	Denied
160P00	John Parnell, Jr., v. Hartsell, Hartsell & White	Plt's PDR	Denied 05/15/00
161P00	Barbara Shaut v. Amy Cannon	Plt's PDR	Denied 05/15/00
162P00	Glenda Walker v. Wayne Coble, Richard Frye, Fidelity and Deposit Co. of Maryland and Aetna Insurance Co.	Plt's PDR	Denied
163P00	Broadus Crabtree v. City of Durham, Michael Ellis & Nationwide Ins. Co.	Def's (City of Durham) PDR	Denied
165P00	Fred Shannonhouse, Employee v. Weyerhaeuser Co., Employer	Def's PDR	Denied
168P00	State v. Reginald Aaron Holmes	Def's Pro Se Motion for Appropriate Relief	Denied
172P00	Popkin Brothers Enterprises, Inc. v. Bd. of Adjustment of Jacksonville & City of Jacksonville	Plaintiff's PDR	Denied
173P00	Terry Clark v. Host Marriott Corp.	Plt's PDR	Denied
174P00	Willie B. Tart v. James Martin & Peggy Martin	Defs' PDR	Allowed
175P00	State v. Steven Clarence Leazer	1. AG's Motion for Temp. Stay 2. AG's Pet. for Writ of Supersedeas 3. AG's PDR 4. Def's Motion to Dissolve Stay	1. Allowed 04/24/00 2. Allowed 3. Allowed 4. Denied
176P00	State v. Thomas Joseph Edvin	Def's Pro Se PWC	Denied
177P00	State v. Bobby Junior Locklear	Def's Pro Se PWC	Denied
178P00	State v. Reginald Sherwood Grady	1. Def's Pro Se NOA 2. Def's Pro Se PWC 3. AG's Motion to Dismiss Appeal	1. - - - 2. Denied 3. Allowed
180P00	State v. Wonald Westmoreland	Def's Pro Se PWC	Denied
184P00	State v. Carl Jeffreys	Def's PDR	Denied
187P00	State v. Penny Elizabeth Jarrett	Def's PDR	Denied
188P00	Tony Dale Howell v. John Wilson & NC Farm Bureau Mutual Ins. Co.	Plt's PDR	Denied
189P00	State v. Stephen Clay Jones, Sr.	1. Def's NOA 2. Def's PDR 3. AG's Motion to Dismiss Appeal	1. - - - 2. Denied 3. Allowed Justice Wainwright Recused
191P00	State v. James D. Rich	1. Def's Pro Se PWC 2. Def's Pro Se Motion to Proceed In Forma Pauperis	1. Denied 2. Allowed
194P00	State v. Pearly Junior Rhodie	Def's Pro Se PWC	Denied
198P00	State v. Raymond Shelton	1. Def's Pro Se PWC 2. Def's Pro Se Petition to Amend PWC	1. Denied 2. Allowed
199P00	State v. Melvin Ollison, Jr.	Def's PDR	Denied
200P00	Ricky Jay Murakami v. Wilmington Star News, Inc.	Plt's PDR	Denied
202P00	State v. George Lesane	1. Def's NOA 2. Def's PDR 3. AG's Motion to Dismiss Appeal	1. - - - 2. Denied 3. Allowed
203P00	Ted F. Cash v. State Farm Mutual Auto Ins. Co.	Plt's PDR	Allowed
204P00	State v. George Lewis Cates	1. Def's NOA 2. Def's PDR 3. State's Motion to Dismiss	1. - - - 2. Denied 3. Allowed
208P00	James Whitaker v. Peggy Akers	Def's PDR	Denied
209P00	State v. Arcadia Logan Jenkins	1. Def's NOA 2. Def's PDR 3. AG's Motion to Dismiss Appeal	1. - - - 2. Denied 3. Allowed
226P00	State v. Freddie Pickett & Derrick Foreman	1. AG's Motion for Temp. Stay 2. AG's Pet. for Writ of Supersedeas 3. AG's PDR 4. Def Foreman's Conditional PDR as to additional issues	1. Denied 2. Denied 3. Denied 4. Denied
267PA99	Alex H. Thompson & wife, Sheila Thompson v. Michael S. Waters, d/b/a/ Waterhouse Realty & Construction & Lee County	Def's (Lee County) Petition for Rehearing	Denied
312A99	Sharon Lovelace, et. al. v. City of Shelby	Def's Pet. for Rehearing	Denied
323A92 - 4	State v. Charles Alonzo Tunstall	Def's Pro Se PWC	Denied
359P99 - 2	State v. Brian Ellis	Def's Pro Se PWC	Denied
379A95 - 2	State v. Jeffrey Karl Meyer	Def's Motion to Amend the Record on Appeal	Item 1.Allowed Item 2. Denied
385P99	William Ruff et.al. v. Parex, Inc., Sto Corp., W.R. Bonsal Co., Continental Stucco Products, Senergy, & Thomas Waterproof Coatings, Dryvit Systems, US Gypsum & Shields Industries	1. Defs' (Parex, Sto Corp., Continental Stucco Products & Dryvit Systems) Pet. for Writ of Supersedeas 2. Defs' (Parex, Sto Corp., Continental Stucco Products & Dryvit) PWC 3. Def's (US Gypsum) PWC 4. Def's (US Gypsum ) Pet. for Writ of Supersedeas 5. Def's (W.R. Bonsal's) Pet. for Writ of Supersedeas 6. Def's (W.R. Bonsal's) PWC	1. Dismissed as Moot 05/23/00 2. Dismissed as Moot 05/23/00 3. Dismissed as Moot 05/23/00 4. Dismissed as Moot 05/23/00 5. Dismissed as Moot 05/23/00 6. Dismissed as Moot 05/23/00
435PA99	Tammie Dobson v. Holly Harris & J.C. Penney Co.	Def's Motion to Strike	Allowed
447P99 - 2	State v. Herbert Chavis	Def's Pro Se Motion for Withdrawal of Attorney	Allowed
480A99	State v. Donald Scanlon	1. Def's Motion for Appropriate Relief 2. Def's Motion for Add't. Time for Oral Argument	1. Allowed See Special Order 2. Denied 05/15/00
484A95 - 2	State v. John McNeil	Def's PWC	Denied
490A93 - 3	State v. Raymond Rowsey	1. Def's PWC to Review Order of Sup. Ct. 2. Def's Pet. for Writ of Supersedeas	1. Denied 2. Denied
515P99 - 2*	Haywood Cannon v Gladys Wiggins Cannon, deceased, Norman Wiggins, Administrator	Plt's Pro Se Pet. for Writ of Habeas Corpus	Denied 05/17/00 Justices Wainwright & Martin Recused
547A88 - 3	State of NC v. Kenneth Lee Boyd	Def's PWC	Denied
567A99	State of NC v. Timothy Earl Blackwell	Def's Pro Se Motion to Set Bail	Dismissed
579PA99	State v. Lamont Claxton Underwood	Def's Counsel's Motion to Withdraw	Allowed 05/11/00
581P99*	Vonda C. Trexler v David Pollock	Def's (Hugh Chatham Memorial Hospital) Motion to Strike Plaintiff's Pet. & Response to Plt's Pet. for Certiorari	Dismissed as Moot 05/08/00
582PA99	John Frost & Carolyn Frost v. Mazda Motor of America & Primus Automotive Financial Services	1. Plts' Motion to Dismiss Appeal 2. Plts' Motion to Withdraw Motion to Dismiss Appeal	1. - - - 2. Allowed
590A99 - 2	State v. David Hunter	Def's PWC	Denied