SUPREME COURT OF NORTH CAROLINA

PETITIONS

Decided by the Court in Conference: 21 November 2002

{Posted on the Internet Web Site: 22 November 2002 at 11:30 a.m.}

COMMON ABBREVIATIONS (Click here for archived petitions)
Abbreviation Full Term
PWC Petition for Writ of Certiorari
MAR Motion for Appropriate Relief
COA North Carolina Court of Appeals
MTS Motion for Temporary Stay
Def Defendant
NOA Notice of Appeal
Plt Plaintiff
PDR Petition for Discretionary Review
Cert Certiorari
AG Attorney General

040P02   Department of Transportation v. Mack Blue and wife, Brenda C. Blue

Department of Transportation v. Pierce B. Irby, et al.  

1. Def's PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31
(COA00-995)

2. Plt's PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31
(COA00-995)  

1. Denied

2. Denied  

044PA02*   Wilda Kay Zimmerman, Employee v. Eagle Electronic Manufacturing Co., Employer and Zurich Insurance Company, Carrier   1. Motion By N.C. Academy of Trial Lawyers for Leave to File Amicus Curiae Brief

2. Defs' Motion to Strike Amicus Curiae Brief of the N.C. Academy of Trial Lawyers  

1. Denied
10/08/02

2. Dismissed as Moot
10/08/02  

050A93-2   State v. Nathan Wayne Bowie   Def's PWC to Review the Order of the Superior Court (91CRS7871- 7872)   Denied  
069P02   Hopineal Hines Best, Individually and as Administratrix of the Estate of H.B. Best v. Wayne Memorial Hospital, Inc., Douglas M. Russell, M.D., John Doe I, John Doe II, John Doe III   1. Def's (Russell) NOA Based Upon a Constitutional Question
(COA00-1337-1449)

2. Def's (Russell) PDR Under
G.S. § 7A-31 (COA00-1337-1449)

3. Plt's Motion to Dismiss Appeal for Lack of Substantial Constitutional Question  

1. --

2. Denied

3. Allowed

 

070P02   State v. Travis Newton Johnson   Def's PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31
(COA00-1374)  
Denied  
076A95-3   State v. Charles Walker   Def's Pro Se Motion to Appoint Counsel   Denied  
080P02   Alchemy Communications Corp. and Alchemy Communications Limited Partnership #1 v. Preston Development Company and Flora Development, LLC   Def-Appellant's (Flora Development) PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31
(COA01-75)  
Denied  
127A02*
 
In the Matter of: Mitchell, M.., a minor child, d.o.b. 12/24/94; In the Matter of Mitchell, K., a minor child, d.o.b. 01/16/98; In the Matter of Mitchell, K.., a minor child, d.o.b. 02/06/96
 
1. Pet's (Guardian ad Litem) Motion for Temporary Stay

2. Pet's (Guardian ad Litem) Petition for Writ of Supersedeas

3. Pet's (Guardian ad Litem) NOA Based Upon a Dissent
(COA01-489-90)
 

1. Allowed
03/12/02

2. --

3. --

 

177P02   Allen Whitaker & Sally M. Whitaker v. Robert M. Gay, M.D., Greensboro Pathology Associates, P.A., D. Patrick Burney, M.D., P. Gregory Hayes, M.D., Clarence H. Owen, M.D., Cardiovascular & Thoracic Surgeons of Greensboro, P.A., Kyle A. Young, M.D., Otis N. Fisher, M.D.; Greensboro Radiology, P.A., and The Moses H. Cone Memorial Hospital Operating Corporation   1. Defs' (Burney, Hayes, Owen and Cardiovascular & Thoracic Surgeons of Greensboro, P.A.) PDR
(COA02-843-Order)

2. Defs' (Burney, Hayes, Owen and Cardiovascular & Thoracic Surgeons of Greensboro, P.A.) PWC to Review the Order of the COA (COA02-843)

3. Plts' Motion for Expedited Ruling on Defs' PDR and Defs' PWC  

1. Denied

2. Denied

3. Dismissed as Moot  

189P02   Glenn Irvin, Hockney, Petitioner v. State, Respondent   Pet's Pro Se Motion to Disqualify Judge William C. Griffin, Jr.   Denied  
195P02   Suzanne Hill et al. v. Mike Taylor   Def's PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31
(COA01-555)  
Denied  
201P02   In the Matter of:
Charles America
Kimberly America
Melissa America  
1. Res' (Gloria America) PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31 (COA01-180)

2. Res' (Roger America, Sr.) PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31 (COA01-180)  

1. Denied

2. Denied  

209P98-3   State v. Victor A. Patterson   Def's Pro Se Petition for Writ of Mandamus   Denied  
235P02   Mamie L. Davis v. General Motors   Plt's Pro Se PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31
(COA01-435)  
Denied  
244P02   William H. Peoples v. General Court of Justice   1. Plt's Pro Se Motion to Supplement Currently Pending Motion
(filed 09/12/02)

2. Plt's Pro Se Motion for Reconsideration (filed 10/28/02)  

1. Dismissed

2. Dismissed

 

264A90-6   State v. Marvin Earl Williams, Jr.   AG's PWC to Review the Order of the Superior Court   Allowed

Butterfield, J.
Recused
 

277A02*   Yolandra Best and Roy Hudson, Petitoner v. Department of Health and Human Services, John Unstead Hospital, Respondent   1. Res' Motion for Temporary Stay

2. Res' Petition for Writ of Supersedeas

3. Res' NOA Based Upon a Dissent
(COA01-118)

4. Motion by The American Civil Liberties Union of N.C. Legal Foundation, Inc. and the N.C. Academy of Trial Lawyers for Leave to File a Brief Amicus Curiae

 

1. Allowed
06/11/02
Stay Dissolved

2. Dismissed as Moot

3. --

4. Allowed

 

282P01-2   State v. Bruce Jerome Holmes   1. Def's Pro Se PWC to Review the Order of the COA (COAP02-270)

2. DEf's Pro Se PWC to Review the Order of the Superior Court  

1. Dismissed

2. Dismissed

 

285P02*   Conseco Finance Servicing Corp. v. Dependable Housing, Inc. et al.   Joint Motion to Withdraw PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31 (COA01-870)   Allowed
11/19/02  
322A02*   Daniel Fabricio Rosero v. Lisa Blake   Plt;s Motion to Amend Brief   Allowed
11/12/02  
327P02-6   State v. Guy Tobias LeGrande   1. Def's Pro Se PWC to Review the Order of the Superior Court

2. Def's Pro Se Petition for Rehearing on Discretionary Review of Order Denying Pet's MAR Filed 20 September 2002 in Stanly County Superior Court  

1. Denied

2. Denied  

341P02   Max Herring, as assignee of Branch Banking & Trust Co. v. Bennett M.. Kessler, Jr.   Plt's PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31
(COA01-1000)  
Denied  
349P02   Skipper Andrews v. Administrative Office of the Courts, and Thomas W. Ross, in his Official Capacity   Plt's PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31
(COA01-551)  
Denied

Martin, J.
Recused
Lake, J.
Recused
 

351P02   State v. Wayne Scott   1. Def's NOA Based Upon a Constitutional Question (COA01-96)

2. Def's PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31
(COA01-96)

3. AG's Motion to Dismiss Def's NOA

4. AG's PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31
(COA01-96)  

1. --

2. Denied

3. Allowed

4. Denied

 

356P00-3   State v. Robert S. Doisey   1. Def's Pro Se PWC to Review the Order of the COA (COAP02-41)

2. Def's Pro Se Motion to Appoint Counsel  

1. Dismissed

2. Denied

Edmunds, J.
Recused
 

369PA01*   Margaret Williams Pitts, Individually and on Behalf of all Persons Similarly Situated v. American Security Insurance Company et al.   1. Def's (Wachovia Bank of N.C., N.A.) Motion for Reconsideration Pursuant to Appellate Rule 2

2. Def's (American Security Insurance Company and Standard Guaranty Insurance Company) Motion for Reconsideration Pursuant to Appellate Rule 2  

1. Denied
11/14/02

2. Denied
11/14/02


Orr,J.
Recused Wainwright, J.
Recused Edmunds, J. Recused
 

399A02*   Roy Futrell, Employee v. Resinall Corporation, Employer and Liberty Mutual Ins. Co., Carrier   1. Defs' Motion for Reconsideration of Order Granting Discretionary Review

2. Defs' Motion for Enlargement of Time  

1. Denied
11/04/02

2. Dismissed as Moot
11/04/02  

435P02   Pearl Kanipe, Employee, v. Lane Upholstery, Hickory Tavern Furniture Co., Employer, Alexsis Risk Management Services, Administrator   Defs' Petition for Reconsideration of Denial of PDR with Supporting Affidavits   Dismissed  
438A02   John W. Nix, Employee v. Collins & Aikman, Co., et al.   Joint Motion to Withdraw Appeal   Allowed  
444A93-3   State v. George Cale Buckner   Def's PWC to Review the Order of the Superior Court   Denied  
444P98-2   State v. Samuel Wayne Guy   1. Def's Pro Se PWC to Review the Order of the Superior Court

2. Def's Pro Se Motion to Appoint Counsel  

1. Denied

2. Denied

 

462P02   Larry Franklin Buchanan v. Brenda Joyce Deitz Weber   1. Def's Motion for Temporary Stay

2. Def's Petition for Writ of Supersedeas

3. Def's PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31
(COA01-978)

4. Def's Consel's Motion to Withdraw  

1.* Allowed
10/31/02
Stay Dissolved

2. Denied

3. Denied

4.* Allowed
11/19/02  

465P02   State v. Jesse Tyann Bracey   Def's PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31
(COA01-953)  
Denied  
466P02   In the Matter of John Cordero v. Mecklenburg County Superior Court   Plt's Pro Se Motion to Expedite   Dismissed as Moot

 

471P02   Daniel B. Cartin v. Shuford Edward Harrison and wife, Renee Edmiston Harrison   Def's PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31
(COA01-820)  
Denied  
473P02   C. Wayne McDonald v. Ervin Dwain Skeen t/a Dwain Skeen Commercial Industrial Real Estate   1. Def's PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31
(COA01-1069)

2. Plt's Conditional PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31 (COA01-1069)
 

1. Denied
10/09/02

2. Dismissed as Moot
10/09/02
 

474P02   Terry Eugene Harris v. Mickey C. Stamey   Def's PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31 (COA01-1475)   Denied  
476A02*   State v. Darlon Dillon Kinlock   1. AG's Motion for Extension of Time to File Brief Five Days From the Date the Court Rules on the Motion to Amend

2. AG's Motion to Amend Record on Appeal  

1. Allowed
11/19/02

2. Allowed
11/19/02  

477P02   In the Matter of: Genie Kennedy, Joseph Kennedy, and Jerri Lynn Draughon,
Minors  
Res' (Jerry Draughon and Irma Jo Draughon) PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31 (COA01-1107)   Denied  
479A01   State v. Shan E. Carter   Def's Pro Se Motion to Remove Current Counsel and to Appoint New Counsel   Denied  
479P02
 
Boney Publishers, Inc. d/b/a The Alamance News v. The Burlington City Council, and Joseph P. Barbour, Mayor, Dr. David L. Maynard, Mayor Pro Tem, David R. Huffman, Mark A. Jones, and Stephen M. Ross, all in their official capacities as officials of the City of Burlington and members of the Burlington City Council
 
Defs' PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31
(COA01-878)

 

Denied
10/09/02  
484P02
 
North Carolina Insurance Guaranty Association v. International Paper Company et al.   1. Plt's Motion to Amend PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31 (COA01-1179)

2. Plt's PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31
(COA01-1179)  

1.* Allowed
10/11/02

2. Denied  

486P02   Godfrey Lumber Company, Inc. v. A. Preston Howard, Jr., and Kerr Stevens, Directors of the North Carolina Department of Environment, Division of Water Quality, in their Official Capacities; North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources; and North Carolina Environmental Management Commission   Plt's PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31
(COA01-1016)  
Denied  
487P02   State v. Charles Gilbert Murphy   Def's PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31 (COA01-695)   Denied  
496P02   Cecil S. Abernathy, Administratrix of the Estate of Bailey L. Abernathy v. Sandoz Chemicals/Clariant Corporation, Employer, et al.   1. Defs' (Sandoz Chemicals/Clariant Corporation and the Travelers Insurance Companies) PWC to Review the Decision of the COA
(COA01-834)

2. Plt's Motion to Deny PDR  

1. Denied

2. Dismissed as Moot

 

501A02   State v. David Ray Phillips   1. Def's Pro Se NOA Based Upon a Constitutional Question
(COA01-1236)

2. AG's Motion to Dismiss Appeal  

1. --

2. Allowed

 

503P02   Eric Dylan Byrd v. James Melvin Adams   Def's PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31
(COA01-1162)  
Denied  
505P02   Timothy McKyer v. Fontella McKyer   Def's PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31
(COA01-1065)  
Denied  
506A02   In Re: Appeal of the Maharishi Spiritual Center of America   1. Watauga County's NOA Based Upon a Dissent (COA01-644)

2. Watauga County's Alternative PDR (COA01-644)  

1. --

2. Denied

 

508P02   State v. Anthony Mercado Scott   Def's Pro Se PWC to Review the Decision of the COA (COA01-1404)   Denied  
514A02   Willie B. Johnson, Employee, v. Southern Tire Sales and Service, Employer, Casualty Reciprocal Exchange, Carrier   1. Defs' NOA Based Upon a Dissent (COA01-917)

2. Defs' PDR as to Additional Issues (COA01-917)  

1. --

2. Denied  

517P02   Daniel G. Dodder and Jo Ann Dodder v. Yates Construction Company, Inc.   Plt's PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31
(COA01-815)  
Denied  
518P02   State v. Tommy Carver   Def's PWC to Review the Decision of the COA (COA00-769)   Denied  
520P02   TGC Development, Inc. v. Aegean Land Company

TGC Development, Inc. v. Rocky Mountain Enterprises

TGC Development, Inc. v. Key West Enterprises  

Defs' PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31
(COA01-544)  
Denied  
521P02   State v. Chris Williams   1. AG's Motion for Temporary Stay

2. AG's Petition for Writ of Supersedeas

3. AG's PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31
(COA01-1400)  

1. Allowed Pending PDR
10/03/02

2. Allowed

3. Allowed
See Special Order  

522A02   Dan Rhyne and Alice Rhyne v. Kmart Corporation et al.   Plt's Motion for Admission Pro Hac Vice (Robert S. Peck)   Allowed  
522A02*   Dan Rhyne and Alice Rhyne v. K-Mart Corporation, Shawn Roberts, and Joseph Hoyle   Def's (K-Mart Corporation) Motion to Admit James C. Grant Pro Hac Vice   Allowed
10/08/02  
525P02   State v. William Tirion Squire   Def's Pro Se PWC to Review the Order of the Superior Court   Dismissed  
526P02   In the Matter of the Imprisonment of James Darryl Christenbury   Pet's Application for Writ of Habeas Corpus   Denied
10/08/02  
529P02   State v. Nathan Maurice Green   1. Def's NOA Based Upon a Constitutional Question
(COA01-1297)

2. Def's PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31
(COA01-1297)

3. AG's Motion to Dismiss Appeal  

1. --

2. Denied

3. Allowed

 

531P02   State v. Vincent Brady Allen   Def's PWC to Review the Order of the COA (COAP02-157)   Dismissed  
533P02   State v. Christopher Wayne Lippard   1. Def's NOA Based Upon a Constitutional Question (COA01-735)

2. Def's PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31
(COA01-735)

3. Def's PWC to Review the Decision of the COA (COA01-735)  

1.Dismissed
Ex mero motu

2. Denied

3. Denied  

536P02   State v. Gregory Allen Gant   Def's PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31
(COA01-1361)  
Denied  
537P02   Leland Midgett v. North Carolina Department of Transportation, Employer, Self- Insured (Key Risk Management, Servicing Agent)   Plt's PWC to Review the Decision of the COA (COA01-1081)   Denied  
538P02   State v. Jon Eric Pimental   Def's PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31
(COA01-1086)  
Denied  
540P02   State v. Michael Scott McRae   1. Def's Pro Se PWC to Review the Decision of the COA (COA96-1328)

2. Def's Pro Se Motion to Proceed In Forma Pauperis  

1. Denied

2. Allowed

 

541P01   State v. Franklin D. Jones, Jr.   Def's Pro Se PWC to Review the Order of the COA (COAP02-669)   Denied  
542P02   Lester Daniel Bryson and John Frank Bowen v. State Superior Court Judges Robert P. Johnston and Forrest D. Bridges   Plts' Pro Se PWC to Review the Order of the COA (COA02-1149)   Denied  
544P02   State v. Ronald Blair Winstead,         II   Def's Petition for Writ of Habeas Corpus   Denied
10/17/02  
547P02*   State v. Carol Lafferty Colt and Daniel Wayne Stephens   1. Defs' Motion for Temporary Stay
(COA01-192)

2. Defs' Petition for Writ of Supersedeas (COA01-192)  

1. Denied
10/31/02  
548P02   Ginger Dayle Hunt, Employee v. Tender Loving Care Home Care Agency, Inc., Employer
Pharmacists Mutual Insurance Company, Carrier  
Plt's PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31
(COA01-1571)  
Denied  
550P02   State v. Terry S. Harris   1. Pet's Pro Se Petition for Writ of Habeas Corpus

2. Pet's Pro Se Petition for Writ of Mandamus

3. Def's Pro Se Motion Pursuant to Appellate Rule 37 of the North Carolina Rules of Appellate Procedure

4. Def's Pro Se Motion to Reconsider and Rehear Petition for Writ of Mandamus

5. Def's Pro Se Petition for Writ of Habeas Corpus

6. Def's Pro Se Petition for Writ of Mandamus  

1.* Denied
10/23/02

2.* Denied
10/23/02

3. Denied

4. Dismissed

5. Denied

6. Denied  

551P02   Richard G. Steeves v. Scotland County Board of Health and Scotland County   1. Res' Motion for Temporary Stay

2. Res' Petition for Writ of Supersedeas (COA01-1271)

3. Res' PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31
(COA01-1271)  

1.* Allowed
10/24/02
Stay Dissolved

2. Denied

3. Denied

 

557P02   State v. John Edward Waddell   1. Def's NOA Based Upon a Constitutional Question
(COA01-1088)

2. Def's PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31
(COA01-1088)

3. AG's Motion to Dismiss  

1. --

2. Denied

3. Allowed

 

558P02*   Pitt and Greene Electric Membership Corporation v. Mary Bryan Cummins Raspberry et al.   Plt's Motion to Withdraw Petition   Allowed
11/12/02  
559P02   Shawn Lynn Lovelace, Administratrix of the Estate of Shayla Meagen Moore, and Sharon Lynn Lovelace, Individually v. City of Shelby and Thomas Lowell Lee   Def's (City of Shelby) PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31 (COA01-1381)   Denied  
563P02

 

In the Matter of:
Spencer Stratton, d.o.b. 04/14/84, et al.

 

1. Res' (Jack and Cathy Stratton) Motion for Temporary Stay

2. Res' (Jack and Cathy Stratton) Petition for Writ of Supersedeas

3. Res' (Jack and Cathy Stratton) NOA Based Upon a Constitutional Question (COA01-1528)

4. Res' (Jack and Cathy Stratton) PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31 (COA01- 1528)

5. Res' (Jack and Cathy Stratton) Motion to Reconsider Denial of Writ of Supersedeas and Motion for Temporary Stay

6. Guardian Ad Litem's Motion to Dismiss NOA  

1. Denied
11/04/02

2. Denied
11/04/02

3. --

4. Denied

5. Dismissed

6. Allowed  

567P02
 
State v. Shawn Dell Kemp

State v. Edward Earl McDowell  

Def's (McDowell's) PDR Under
G.S. § 7A-31 (COA01-1345)  
Denied  
571P02*   John Kirby v. Richard Brown   Pet's Pro Se Petition for Writ of Mandamus   Denied
11/12/02  
572P02   State v. Greg Dewan Smith   1. Def's Pro Se PWC to Review the Decision of the COA (COA01-1324)

2. Def's Pro Se Motion to Proceed In Forma Pauperis  

1. Denied

2. Allowed

 

573P02   State v. Sal Siracusa   Def's Pro Se PWC to Review the Decision of the COA (COA01-1148)   Denied  
574A97-2   State v. Errol Duke Moses   Def's PWC to Review the Orders of the Superior Court   Denied  
575P02   State v. Marcus Rudolph Keys   1. Def's Pro Se PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31 (COA02-44)

2. Def's Pro Se Motion to Be Heard  

1. Denied

2. Denied

 

577P02   Samuel Wayne Guy v. Beck, et al.   Plt's Pro Se Petition for Writ of Mandamus   Dismissed  
580P02
 
State v. Gordie L. Penson
 
1. Def's Pro Se PWC to Review the Order of the COA (COAP02-537)

2. Def's Pro Se Motion to Proceed In Forma Pauperis

3. Def's Pro Se Motion to Appoint Counsel  

1. Denied

2. Allowed

3. Denied

 

585A97-2   State v. Jimmie Wayne Lawrence   Def's PWC to Review the Order of the Superior Court   Denied  
586P02   State v. Tony Robert Jones   Def's Pro Se Petition for Writ of Mandamus   Denied  
589P02   State v. Nikita Coleman   Def's Pro Se Petition for Habeas Corpus to Set Aside Conviction on Newly Discovered Evidence   Denied  
593P02   State v. Robert Wayne Smith   1. AG's Motion for Temporary Stay

2. AG's Petition for Writ of Supersedeas

3. AG's PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31
(COA02-417)

 

1. Allowed

2.

3.

 

600P01   Travis Clay Pinney, William H. Dick v. State Farm Mutual Insurance Company, Eugene Davis and David Harling   1. Plt's PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31
(COA00-1007)

2. Defs' Conditional PDR as to Additional Issues (COA00-1007)  

1. Denied

2. Denied  

621A01   Margaret Wrenn Anderson v. Dr. Dean George Assimos, M.D., Dr. Lawrence Kroovard, M.D., Dr. Mark R. Hess, M.D., Wake Forest University Physicians, Wake Forest University Baptist Medical Center, The Medical Center of Bowman Gray School of Medicine and North Carolina Baptist Hospital and The North Carolina Baptist Hospitals, Incorporated   1. Defs' NOA Based Upon a Dissent
(COA00-587)

2. Defs' NOA Based Upon a Constitutional Question (COA00-587)

3. Defs' Motion to Strike and/or Disregard all Documents Contained in Appendix to Plt's-Appellee's Brief

4. Plt's Motion to Dismiss Appeal

5. Plt's Motion to Sanction Appellants for Failure to Comply with the Rules of Appellate Procedure

6. Plt's Amended Motion to Dismiss Appeal

7. Plt's (Amended) Motion to Sanction Appellants for Failure to Comply with the Rules of Appellate Procedure

8. Plt's Motion to Strike and Set Aside the Amicus Brief of the N.C. Medical Society et al.

9. Amicus Motion for Admission Pro Hac Vice (Robert S. Peck)

10. Motion by the Association of Trial Lawyers of America and The American Civil Liberties Union of N.C. Legal Foundation, Inc. for Leave to File Amicus Curiae Brief

11. Defs' Motion to Strike the Amicus Curiae Brief and Attached Appendix of the N.C. Academy of Trial Lawyers

12. N.C. Academy of Trial Lawyers' Motion for Leave to Submit Affidavits to the Court

13. Plt's Motion for Permission to Proceed In Forma Pauperis

14. Association of Trial Lawyers of America and the American Civil Liberties Union of N.C. Legal Foundation, Inc.'s Motion for Leave to Participate in Oral Argument
 

1. --

2. Retain

3.* Dismissed as Moot

4.* Dismissed as Moot

5.* Dismissed as Moot

6.* Dismissed as Moot

7.* Dismissed as Moot

8.* Denied
03/21/02

9.* Allowed
03/21/02

10.* Allowed
03/21/02

11.*Dismissed as Moot

12.* Dismissed as Moot

13.* Allowed
09/02/02

14.* Allowed
09/04/02  

641P01   William Edward Vaughn v. CVS Revco D.S., Inc. and Greg Deese   1. Def's PDR Under G.S. § 7A-31
(COA00-1046)

2. Plt's PDR as to Additional Issues  

1. Denied

2. Dismissed as Moot

.